This is a David and Goliath scrap, and a friendly one.
On one side: Stewart Vickers, known on the circuit as SEO Jesus. A one-man operation, building in public from a VPS he runs himself. On the other: Gareth Hoyle, founder and managing director of Marketing Signals, a UK search agency that has been going since 2007 and works with mid-market and enterprise brands. On his own site, Gareth puts the current team at 30 to 40 people. That is nearly twenty years of agency experience, and a proper bench, lined up against one person and a server.
Gareth’s graph maps the wider conference circuit. Stewart’s is narrower, and goes deeper on the stages he has actually stood on — a world map, pilgrimage trails for the people who have followed him around, and a tongue-in-cheek ranking he calls Holy Centrality.
Have a look at both. Then vote. We’ll let the public decide.
What Gareth built vs what Stewart built
One enterprise team. One guy in a bar in Thailand. You decide.
Figures 17 November 2026.
Stewart Vickers (SEO Jesus)
What Stewart built
The Holy Centrality graph: 318 nodes, 760 edges, with speaker and event leaderboards, and Disciples, Congregation and Lost Sheep tiers
A world map of his talks
His own MCP server (7 tools)
An entity map (426 entities, 819 relations)
llms.txt
iCal and JSON feeds
125 profiles, with certificates and badges
A movers changelog
A page of about 207 KB
Stewart says he built this with Grok Bot, on his own VPS, largely from a bar in Thailand — in his words, “literally while in a bar in Thailand.”
Gareth Hoyle (Marketing Signals)
What Gareth built
A speaker and conference site
A knowledge graph of 809 people and 100 events
About 1,518 URLs
An entity map (25 entities)
An MCP server (3 tools)
llms.txt
A profile claim form
Stewart says this was built with Claude, and with an enterprise SEO team.
A note on the tools. Stewart says he built his graph with Grok agents, running on that VPS. He says Gareth built his with Claude. Those are Stewart’s claims about the tooling; they have not been independently verified. The agency facts above are from Marketing Signals’ and Gareth’s own public sites.
Built around Stewart: Holy Centrality leaderboards, a world map, and trails for speakers who have followed him from city to city. Depth, not the whole circuit.
Figures 17 November 2026. Stewart’s counts are from the live graph and EntityMap on this site. Gareth’s are from the Marketing Signals graph, EntityMap and public sitemap, observed the same day. Page weights are approximate. On Gareth’s graph, Stewart is currently listed with one talk, UK SEO Summit 2026.
Look at both
A preview of each graph, composed so you can actually read them. Open the live versions to search, filter and follow the trails.
Stewart Vickers (SEO Jesus)
SEO Speaker Knowledge Graph: who shared the stage with SEO Jesus
Counted on the Asia/Bangkok calendar. One vote per connection per day, stored as a one-way hash, not your IP. This is a straw poll, not a scientific survey. Gareth, you are very welcome to vote, and to bring the team.
Questions
What is this vote?
A public, playful comparison of two knowledge graphs of the search-conference circuit: Stewart Vickers’ graph on stewartvickers.com, and Gareth Hoyle’s graph on Marketing Signals. It is a friendly contest, not a professional attack. Have a look at both, then pick one.
Who is Stewart Vickers?
Stewart Vickers is a London-based SEO speaker, AI speaker and automation speaker, known on the circuit as SEO Jesus. He is the founder of SEO Jesus (Serpply Ltd) and built the graph, map and Holy Centrality index on this site.
Who is Gareth Hoyle?
Gareth Hoyle is the founder and managing director of Marketing Signals, a UK search-marketing agency that has been going since 2007. The firm works with mid-market and enterprise brands on SEO, PPC, digital PR and GEO. On his own site, Gareth puts the current team at 30 to 40 people.
Did Stewart really use Grok, and Gareth Claude?
Those are Stewart’s claims about the tooling, and they have not been independently verified. The comparison of a one-man VPS operation with a long-established agency is the framing Stewart is putting to a public vote, not a statement of fact about how Gareth’s graph was built.
Are these the live graphs?
They are composed previews, so you can compare them at a glance. Stewart’s panel is a still of his graph at a readable zoom, taken 17 November 2026. Gareth’s site sends headers that block other sites from embedding its pages, so his panel is a screenshot of marketingsignals.com, taken the same day. The buttons open each live graph in a new tab, where you can search, filter and click around.
What are Disciples, Congregation and Lost Sheep doing here?
Those names come from Stewart’s tongue-in-cheek Holy Centrality ranking of speakers on his graph. On this page they are just a bit of ceremony for the vote: Lost Sheep before you ballot, Congregation once you have voted today, and Disciple if you come back on consecutive days. The streak lives in your browser, not in the ballot box, and it does not change the count. It is not a comment on which champion you pick.
How are the votes counted?
One vote per person per day, counted on the Asia/Bangkok calendar. After you vote, you will see today’s tug of war and the all-time totals. The daily ballot resets at midnight in Bangkok; the all-time count keeps running. Votes are stored on Stewart’s Cloudflare account. The site keeps a one-way hash of your IP for the day, not the IP itself, so the same connection cannot vote twice before midnight in Bangkok. An optional Cloudflare Turnstile check can be switched on against spam. This is a straw poll, not a scientific survey.
Look, then decide.
Open both graphs, click around, and come back. The vote stays open.